Aquagear vs Brita [An In-Depth Comparison Guide]


In a world where the quality of our tap water is increasingly under scrutiny, water pitcher filters have emerged as a convenient and popular solution for many households. As health-conscious consumers, we’re often faced with the dilemma of choosing the right filtration system that strikes a balance between efficiency, cost, and ease of use.

Two prominent players of the best water filter pitchers in this space, Aquagear and Brita, have gained recognition for their water pitcher filters. This article aims to provide a detailed comparison to assist you in making an informed decision tailored to your specific needs.

Aquagear vs Brita Comparison Chart

Before we dive into the nitty-gritty details, let’s take a quick glance at how Aquagear and Brita stack up against each other in a concise chart:

Criteria Aquagear Pitcher Brita Everyday Pitcher
Overview High-quality build, long-lasting filters Popular and widely available, budget-friendly
Filter Lifespan 150 gallons 40 gallons
Contaminants Removed Heavy metals, fluoride, chlorine Chlorine, mercury, copper, zinc, cadmium
Cost Moderate Budget-friendly
Filter Replacement Cost Moderate Affordable
Other Models Offered Aquagear Water Filter Pitcher Brita Stream, Brita Ultramax
Customer Reviews and Complaints Positive reviews, minor complaints Mixed reviews, common filter issues
Pros & Cons Balanced filtration, durable design Established brand, affordable options



Brita Everyday Pitcher

The Brita Everyday Pitcher, a stalwart in the water filtration market, is a testament to Brita’s commitment to providing accessible and reliable water purification. This classic model is widely recognized for its budget-friendly nature, making it a popular choice for families and individuals looking for a practical yet effective solution.

The Brita Everyday Pitcher is designed with simplicity in mind, offering a straightforward and easy-to-use system for everyday hydration.

Aquagear Pitcher

In the realm of water pitcher filters, Aquagear takes a slightly different approach. The Aquagear Pitcher is positioned as a premium choice, appealing to those who prioritize quality and efficiency. The pitcher boasts a high-quality build that emphasizes durability, addressing concerns about wear and tear over time.

Aquagear positions itself as a brand dedicated to comprehensive filtration, particularly focusing on removing heavy metals and fluoride from tap water. While it comes with a higher initial cost, Aquagear promises a longer lifespan for both the pitcher and its filters.

By providing an overview of each brand’s flagship pitcher, we can start to discern the distinctive qualities that might influence our choice between the practicality of Brita and the premium features of Aquagear.

As we delve deeper into the specifics, it becomes clear that personal preferences and priorities will play a crucial role in determining the best fit for individual households.

Filter Comparison

Water pitcher filters are only as good as their ability to remove contaminants, and this is where the rubber meets the road for consumers. Let’s break down the filter media capabilities of both the Brita Everyday Pitcher and the Aquagear Pitcher.

Brita Everyday Pitcher

Brita has established itself as a reliable option for basic water filtration needs. The Everyday Pitcher utilizes Brita’s standard filters, which are effective in removing common contaminants found in tap water.

Brita Pitchers will easily remove contaminants like chlorine (remove chlorine taste), mercury, copper, zinc, and cadmium. This makes Brita a suitable choice for users concerned about typical impurities but not necessarily targeting more specific or heavy-duty contaminants.

Aquagear Pitcher

Aquagear takes filtration to the next level by focusing on a broader range of contaminants. The Aquagear Pitcher is equipped to handle heavy metals, fluoride, and chlorine. This means it can provide more comprehensive purification, particularly for individuals who live in areas with higher concentrations of heavy metals or fluoride in their water supply.

While both heavy metals and fluoride are not always present in every tap water source, the Aquagear is tailored to cater to those who want an extra layer of protection against these specific elements.

Contaminants Removed Comparison Chart

To visualize the differences in contaminant removal capabilities, let’s compare the two pitchers using a chart:

Contaminant Brita Everyday Pitcher Aquagear Pitcher
Chlorine Yes Yes
Mercury Yes Yes
Copper Yes Yes
Zinc Yes Yes
Cadmium Yes Yes
Fluoride Limited Effective
Heavy Metals Limited Comprehensive


As the chart illustrates, both pitchers do a commendable job of removing common contaminants like chlorine, mercury, copper, zinc, and cadmium. However, Aquagear pulls ahead by effectively targeting fluoride and offering comprehensive removal of heavy metals.

This can be a crucial factor for individuals with specific health concerns related to these contaminants or those who simply want the highest level of water purity available in a pitcher form.

Cost Comparison

Cost is a significant factor for many consumers when deciding on a water pitcher filter. Let’s delve into the financial aspects of both the Brita Everyday Pitcher and the Aquagear Pitcher to help you make an informed decision based on your budget considerations.

Brita Everyday Pitcher

One of the key strengths of Brita, and particularly the Everyday Pitcher, lies in its affordability. Brita has long been known for providing accessible and budget-friendly water filtration solutions.

The Everyday Pitcher itself is competitively priced, making it an attractive option for a wide range of consumers. The initial investment is low, and replacement filters are also relatively inexpensive, contributing to the overall cost-effectiveness of choosing Brita.

Aquagear Pitcher

In contrast, the Aquagear Pitcher comes with a slightly higher price tag. This reflects the brand’s positioning as a more premium option in the water filtration market. While the initial cost might be a consideration for some, it’s essential to weigh this against the enhanced features and potentially longer lifespan of the pitcher and filters.

The Aquagear emphasizes durable construction, and its filters have an impressive lifespan of 150 gallons compared to Brita’s 40 gallons. This longevity can lead to less frequent filter replacements, potentially offsetting the higher initial investment over time.

When considering the cost of ownership for both pitchers, it’s crucial to factor in not only the upfront price but also ongoing expenses related to filter replacements. Let’s explore this aspect in more detail.

Filter Lifespan and Replacement Cost Comparison

The lifespan of water pitcher filters and the cost of their replacements are critical factors in evaluating the long-term affordability and convenience of a filtration system. Let’s take a closer look at how the Brita Everyday Pitcher and the Aquagear Pitcher compare in terms of filter life and replacement costs.

Brita Everyday Pitcher

The Brita Everyday Pitcher utilizes Brita’s standard filters, which generally have a lifespan of approximately 40 gallons of water. While the lifespan of Brita filters are suitable for many households and ensures efficient filtration for a reasonable period, it does mean that users may find themselves replacing filters more frequently compared to models with longer lifespans.

The replacement cost for Brita filters is one of its standout features. Brita has positioned itself as an accessible and budget-friendly option, and this is reflected in the affordability of replacement filters.

The combination of a low initial cost and inexpensive replacement filters makes the Brita Everyday Pitcher an attractive choice for cost-conscious consumers who prioritize ongoing affordability.

Aquagear Pitcher

In contrast, the Aquagear Pitcher boasts an impressive filter lifespan of 150 gallons. This is significantly longer than the lifespan of Brita filters. While the initial cost of Aquagear filters is slightly higher, the extended lifespan means that users may need to replace filters less frequently.

The replacement cost for Aquagear filters, when viewed over the longer lifespan, can be more balanced than it initially appears. While the upfront cost may be a consideration for some, the potential reduction in the frequency of filter replacements can contribute to cost savings in the long run.

Comparing the two pitchers in terms of filter lifespan and replacement filter costs underscores a trade-off between immediate affordability and long-term convenience. The Brita Everyday Pitcher excels in providing a low-cost entry point and budget-friendly replacement filters, making it an accessible option for those who prioritize upfront savings.

On the other hand, the Aquagear Pitcher, with its longer filter lifespan, offers a potential cost advantage over time, especially for users who appreciate the convenience of less frequent filter replacements.

Other Types of Water Pitcher Filter Models Each Company Offers

Both Aquagear and Brita extend their product lines beyond their best flagship water pitchers, offering users a variety of options to cater to different preferences and requirements.


Brita has diversified its lineup to include models such as the Brita Stream and Brita Ultramax, among others. The Brita Stream, for instance, emphasizes faster filtration, allowing users to pour and drink without waiting for the water to pass through the filter.

The Brita Ultramax, on the other hand, features a larger capacity, suitable for households with higher water consumption. These additional models showcase Brita’s commitment to providing solutions that address specific needs, whether it’s speed, capacity, or convenience.


Aquagear, while maintaining a more focused product line, is known for its emphasis on quality and comprehensive filtration. The Aquagear Water Filter Pitcher, the flagship model, exemplifies the brand’s dedication to durable design and thorough purification.

While Aquagear may not have as extensive a range as Brita, the brand prioritizes excellence in the models it does offer.

Customer Reviews and Complaints Consensus

Customer feedback is invaluable when assessing the performance and satisfaction levels associated with water pitcher filters. Here’s a breakdown of the consensus from customer reviews and common complaints for both Aquagear and Brita:


Customer reviews for Brita are generally positive, with many users praising the affordability and accessibility of the products. The brand’s popularity is evident in its widespread usage. However, some common complaints revolve around filter issues, including occasional clogging or a decrease in filtration efficiency over time.

While these issues are not universal, they are noteworthy for potential buyers to consider.


Aquagear tends to receive positive reviews for its durable design and comprehensive filtration. Users appreciate the pitcher’s ability to remove a wide range of contaminants, including heavy metals and fluoride. However, there have been occasional minor complaints, such as preferences for improvements in the pouring spout design.

Overall, Aquagear has cultivated a positive reputation for delivering on its promises of high-quality filtration.

Pros & Cons

Let’s delve into the strengths and weaknesses of both brands, considering the key features that define each water pitcher filter:



  • Established brand: Brita has a long history and widespread recognition.
  • Budget-friendly options: Brita provides affordable solutions for consumers.
  • Availability: Brita products are widely available in various retail outlets.


  • Limited fluoride removal: Brita filters may have limitations in removing certain contaminants like fluoride.
  • Shorter filter lifespan: Brita filters typically have a lifespan of 40 gallons, necessitating more frequent replacements.



  • Comprehensive filtration: Aquagear is known for its ability to remove heavy metals and fluoride.
  • Durable design: Aquagear emphasizes a high-quality build for its pitchers.
  • Longer filter lifespan: Aquagear filters have a lifespan of 150 gallons, leading to less frequent replacements.


  • Higher initial cost: Aquagear pitchers may come with a slightly higher upfront price tag.
  • Limited model range: Aquagear’s product line is more focused compared to some competitors.

These pros and cons offer a snapshot of what each brand excels at and where they might have some limitations. Users should consider their specific needs and priorities when deciding between Brita and Aquagear.

In conclusion, while Brita’s widespread availability and affordability make it a popular choice, Aquagear stands out with its emphasis on comprehensive filtration and durable design. The right choice will depend on individual preferences, water quality concerns, and budget considerations.

My Choice After Comparing the Aquagear vs Brita Water Pitcher Filters (Conclusion)

Choosing between Aquagear and Brita water pitcher filters ultimately boils down to personal preferences, priorities, and individual needs. Here’s a breakdown of factors to consider when determining which brand might be the better fit for you:

Budget and Affordability: If you’re looking for an affordable yet reliable option with widespread availability, Brita might be your go-to choice. Its budget-friendly pitchers and filters make it accessible to a wide range of consumers.

Comprehensive Filtration: If removing a broad spectrum of contaminants, including heavy metals and fluoride, is a top priority, Aquagear shines in this aspect. The brand’s focus on thorough purification may be especially appealing to those living in areas with specific water quality concerns.

Filter Lifespan and Replacement Cost: Consider how frequently you’re comfortable replacing filters. Brita offers a cost-effective solution with shorter filter lifespans, while Aquagear provides potential long-term savings with filters lasting up to 150 gallons.

Brand Reputation and Reviews: Both brands have their strengths and weaknesses based on customer reviews. Brita’s established brand presence and widespread use are advantages, while Aquagear receives praise for its durable design and comprehensive filtration. Consider which aspects align more closely with your priorities.

Other Model Offerings: If you have specific preferences for pitcher size, speed of filtration, or other features, explore the additional models each brand offers beyond their flagship pitchers.

Water Quality Concerns: Assess the specific contaminants present in your tap water and match them with the filtration capabilities of each brand. If heavy metals and fluoride are prevalent in your water source, Aquagear might be the more suitable choice.

In conclusion, your choice between Aquagear and Brita should align with your unique needs and priorities. If you prioritize affordability, widespread availability, and are content with standard filtration, Brita is likely the better fit.

On the other hand, if you seek comprehensive filtration, a longer filter lifespan, and are willing to invest a bit more upfront, Aquagear could be the preferred option.

FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)

Can I use well water with these pitchers?

While both pitchers are designed for tap water, it’s recommended to check the specific water quality guidelines provided by each brand. Well water may contain unique contaminants that could affect the performance of the filters.

Are Aquagear filters compatible with Brita pitchers?

No, Aquagear and Brita filters are not interchangeable. Each brand’s filters are specifically designed for their respective pitchers.

How often should I replace the filters?

The frequency of filter replacement depends on the model and brand. Brita filters typically have a lifespan of 40 gallons, while Aquagear filters last up to 150 gallons. Follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for optimal performance.

Do these pitchers remove hard water minerals?

Water filter pitchers, even the best water filter pitcher will primarily focus on removing contaminants like chlorine, heavy metals, and certain impurities. Water pitchers may not be designed to address hard water minerals. Consider a water softener if hard water minerals are a concern.

Can I filter water for cooking and other purposes with these pitchers?

These pitchers are designed for drinking water purification. While filtered water can enhance the taste of beverages and improve the quality of ice, they may not be suitable for filtering water used in cooking or for appliances like humidifiers.

Leave a Comment